Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse is a mid-tier footwear chain that sells athletic, casual, dress and seasonal shoes alongside accessories and insoles.
The catch is its tight regional split: 88 stores cluster heavily in Florida, where warm-weather stock gets deeper shelf space than the boots northern shoppers need.
Three Fort Myers locations and three Orlando stores hold the densest inventory, while the shared Rack Room Shoes loyalty program lets points carry across 500-plus sister stores.
Athletic Shoes
The athletic floor at Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse is where I usually head first, and for good reason.
The selection runs from daily trainers to court shoes and cleats, with Nike and Adidas sitting right beside private labels like Bjorndal and Xappeal.
Support and cushioning are the non-negotiables here; these shoes are built for actual movement, not just the look of it.
Rack Room Shoes and Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse brands offer a variety of styles for women, men, and children in athletic, comfort, and dress categories.
That breadth matters when you’re trying to match a shoe to a real workout habit rather than a vague intention.
I tend to gravitate toward the name brands for running, where midsole tech has advanced enough to matter, but the private labels hold their own for gym sessions and casual sports.
Start by matching the shoe to what you actually do: cushioning for high-impact miles, stability for lateral cuts and jumps.
Try to get by with one pair for everything and you’ll end up replacing both your shoes and your knees faster than necessary.
Casual Shoes
Slip-ons and lace-ups make up the bulk of what most women reach for daily, and Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse stocks enough of both to cover a commute and a Saturday brunch without changing pairs.
The private labels are where the value sits.
Xappeal and Bjorndal cost less than the name brands and hold up about as well for everyday walking, though the leather on Bjorndal’s mules softens faster than I’d like around the heel collar and Xappeal’s memory foam insoles compress after roughly six months of regular wear.
That trade-off matters less if you rotate between two or three pairs, which is what I would do at those price points.
The known brands, your Skechers and Clarks and Naturalizers, run $10 to $30 higher but use denser midsoles and stitching that does not fray at the stress points.
For a shoe that lives under a desk five days a week, the extra cost pays out in months of usable life.
I would put that money toward whatever pair gets the most hours on concrete or carpet, then fill the weekend slot with a private label that can afford to get scuffed at a farmers market.
Dress Shoes
Dress shoes at Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse fill a real gap for women who need to look polished without draining the shoe budget.
The selection leans toward pumps, wedges, and heeled sandals that work for office dress codes or evening events, with enough variety in toe shape and heel height that you can match them to what you already own rather than rebuilding your wardrobe around them.
The balance here is between how the shoe looks across a room and how it feels by hour three.
I have found that the mid-range heel height, around 2 to 3 inches, tends to offer the most wearability for full workdays, and Off Broadway stocks this zone heavily.
Patent finishes and pointed toes read more formal; rounded toes and textured materials shift the same silhouette toward business casual.
Pricing sits below department store equivalents without hitting the quality floor where construction becomes obvious.
You are still getting synthetic uppers in many cases, which means less breathability than leather, but the compromise is reasonable if you need two or three pairs in rotation rather than one investment piece.
For occasional wear, the cost-per-use math works out fine.
Sandals
Open-toed styles at Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse lean heavily on warm-weather months, with inventory typically peaking from March through August and tapering sharply once temperatures drop below consistent sandal weather.
Materials run the practical range you’d expect at a mid-tier warehouse chain: molded EVA footbeds for the under-$35 pool slides, woven synthetic uppers on gladiator styles, and the occasional leather-look strappy sandal that photographs better than it breathes.
Florida stores stock these more aggressively than northern locations for obvious reasons.
Fort Myers and Orlando each carry 3 locations, the highest concentration in the entire 88-store network, which means those markets see deeper sandal selection and longer seasonal holds than a Chicago or Denver store that needs boot space by October.
I would not drive across state lines expecting a dramatically different assortment, but if you are already in southwest or central Florida during shoulder season, those stores are your best bet for finding last-season clearance sandals still on the rack when your local store has already reset for fall.
Boots
Boots at Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse split between two jobs: the ones built for cold mornings and the ones meant to read as fashion.
With 88 stores total, the mix you find depends heavily on where you live. Three of those stores sit in Fort Myers and another three in Orlando, with Kissimmee, Pooler, Lakeland, Miami, and Jacksonville each holding two.
That southern concentration tilts stock toward lighter, shorter styles you can wear through a mild winter. Northern markets carry the heavier stuff: insulated work boots, waterproof hikers, the kind of lug sole that handles actual snow.
Work boots and fashion boots share wall space, though rarely the same construction. A steel toe or waterproof membrane matters more in Minnesota than in Florida, and the inventory reflects it.
If you are shopping online, the full range is available; in person, your local store may top out at a fashion Chelsea or a utility boot that stops at water-resistant.
The regional split is real, and worth checking before you make the trip.
Accessories
Socks and insoles are where a shoe purchase either lasts or falls apart in the first month.
Off Broadway carries the usual athletic and dress sock lines, plus gel and memory-foam insoles that I think are worth trying before you commit to replacing a shoe that pinches.
The insoles run about half what you’d pay at a pharmacy for comparable support, and staff will usually let you open the package to feel the arch height before you buy.
Shoe care is thinner here than at dedicated leather shops, but the basics are covered: waterproofing spray, suede erasers, and cedar shoe trees for the dress styles.
I keep a spray can by my door and use it more than I expected; it adds maybe two minutes to leaving the house and extends the life of suede boots noticeably.
The loyalty program is shared with Rack Room Shoes, which operates 500-plus stores across 36 states.
Points accumulate on these accessory purchases the same way they do on boots or running shoes, so a $12 insole pack still moves you toward the reward threshold.
That matters more than it sounds if you’re someone who buys care items in small batches rather than restocking once a year.
Store Locations
Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse runs 88 stores across the United States as of October 2026, with the tightest clusters in Florida: Fort Myers and Orlando each host three locations, while Kissimmee, Pooler, Lakeland, Miami, and Jacksonville follow with two apiece.
Most of the remaining stores sit singly in smaller markets across the Southeast and beyond.
The chain operates under the same ownership as Rack Room Shoes, which maintains over 500 stores in 36 states.
That relationship matters if you are hunting a specific size or style; inventory sometimes shifts between the two banners, and returns at one typically work at the other.
For shoppers near those Florida hubs, the density means easier exchanges and less need to commit to a purchase without trying the fit first.
Brand Offerings
Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse stocks both familiar names and house brands you will not see elsewhere.
Nike and Adidas sit on the same wall as Bjorndal, Bluefin, and Xappeal, three private labels built for the store. That split matters because the private labels let the buyer move between price bands without leaving the building.
A woman who came in for a discounted Adidas runner can grab a Bjorndal casual flat for the same closet without paying the logo tax twice.
The house brands fill gaps the big names ignore. Xappeal tends toward trend-forward silhouettes, Bjorndal leans into everyday comfort construction, and Bluefin covers the athletic-casual middle.
I would not expect the private labels to outlast a Nike sole under hard miles, but for desk-to-dinner wear or a season of light walking, the materials and stitching hold up well enough that the savings stop feeling like a compromise.
The real win is choice density: one trip, multiple budgets, no need to cross-shop three stores to compare.
Loyalty and Online Shopping
Points earned at Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse carry over to Rack Room Shoes, so a single program covers both stores.
That is useful if you shop whichever is closer on a given trip, but the shared program means the same rules apply across both brands.
Sources note the connection and the basic benefit of pooling purchases, not the rate at which points build or the exact threshold for a reward.
Off Broadway also offers buy online, pick up in-store. In practice, this lets you reserve a pair from the warehouse inventory and collect it the same day rather than waiting on shipping.
It works best when your size is in stock and you are passing the location anyway; the value drops if the pair you want is sitting at a different warehouse, since transfers between stores are not guaranteed.
For a shopper deciding between ordering from Off Broadway or from a site with faster home delivery, the convenience depends entirely on proximity.
I would use the loyalty program passively, not actively.
The points are a side effect of purchases I would make anyway, not a reason to consolidate spending. The in-store pickup, by contrast, earns its place for last-minute needs or for trying on a half-size up and down before committing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse stores are in the United States?
There are 88 Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse stores in the United States as of October 2026.
The densest clusters are in Florida, where Fort Myers and Orlando each have three locations. Most remaining stores sit singly across smaller markets in the Southeast and beyond.
What types of shoes does Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse offer?
Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse sells athletic, casual, dress shoes, sandals, and boots, plus accessories like socks and insoles.
Athletic styles range from daily trainers to court shoes and cleats. Dress shoes lean toward pumps, wedges, and heeled sandals for office or evening wear.
What happened to Off Broadway Shoes?
Nothing happened to Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse; it still operates 88 stores across the United States.
The chain sits under the same ownership as Rack Room Shoes, which runs over 500 stores in 36 states. The two brands share a loyalty program and sometimes shift inventory between them.
Is Off Broadway the same as Rack Room Shoes?
Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse and Rack Room Shoes are separate store banners owned by the same company, the Deichmann Group.
They share a loyalty program, so points earned at one apply to the other, and returns at one location typically work at the other. The two brands carry similar categories but target slightly different market positions.
Are Off Broadway shoes real or fake?
Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse sells authentic footwear from licensed brands, not counterfeits.
The store stocks genuine Nike, Adidas, and other name brands plus its own private labels like Bjorndal and Xappeal. Those house brands are produced specifically for the chain, not knockoffs of other companies’ designs.
Are Off Broadway shoes good quality?
Quality at Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse varies by price tier and intended use. Name brands like Nike and Adidas use advanced midsole tech for serious athletic wear.
The private labels hold up fine for desk-to-dinner wear or light walking, though materials like synthetic uppers and memory foam insoles compress faster than premium equivalents under heavy use.
